Stacks Image 64

Broken Inheritance

an essay by Richard Aronowitz first published in:
The London Magazine issue Dec. 2020 | Jan. 2021
If you want to understand history, you need to go out and find its stories. You have to dig them out, unearth them, like archaeologists uncovering traces of earlier civilizations. These stories, the really important ones, are never written down in books.

I spent much of one hot summer’s day in Haifa up in a cool, sun- dappled apartment on a quiet residential street at the bottom of the steps leading up to the Shrine of  the Báb and its gardens on Mount Carmel. I was there to meet Fishel Rotstein. I had tracked down his telephone number through a colleague, Estee, in Tel Aviv some years earlier. As it turned out, he lived on the same street as her Holocaust-survivor mother. I had called Fishel completely out of the blue from my family’s Cotswold stone cottage and told him that I was his late friend Isy Aronowitz’s great- nephew. His first words on hearing this were ‘You are a Jew. It’s very hard to be a Jew.’

Fishel knew this better than most. He wore a square, gold medallion hanging on a chain around his neck inscribed in Hebrew and English: In memory of my family who perished in the Holocaust. My parents Moishe and Sheindl, my brothers and sisters Shimon, Isaac, Samuel, Raisel and Freindl. I did not want to look at it but could not stop myself from looking at it. This is what he told me in his thick Polish accent, his blue eyes twinkling in the sunlight that was streaming through the windows: when he and my great-uncle Isy arrived at Auschwitz from the small labour camp of Eberswalde in Brandenburg, they both had the shits. In the sanitation room for new arrivals, they saw a trailing tail of  paper hanging down from high up on  a beam. One climbed up on the other’s shoulders and pulled at the end of the paper so that they could clean themselves and out tumbled some gold coins. I don’t know what denomination the coins were, or even in which country they were minted. Isy and Fishel were both tailors by trade and Fishel sewed the coins into the belt of his camp uniform. Those coins helped them survive Auschwitz, buying extra rations here and a blindly-turned eye there, from late August 1943 to the early new year of 1945, when they were moved further west to Buchenwald near Weimar in Thuringia so that the Nazis could evade the advance of the Russians and possible liberation of their prisoners. This story was not passed down to me in my family. I had to go out and find it.


It’s all in the files, the meticulous records, the typed lists and inventories and statements and reports that the Nazis kept, if you only go into the archives and look for them. My grandmother Miriam Aronowitz was deported from Wuppertal-Elberfeld on the 10 November 1941 to the Minsk Ghetto. Wagons loaded with two hundred and sixty-four Jews from Wuppertal-Elberfeld and the surrounding area waited on sidings at Wuppertal-Steinbeck station for Sonderzug (Special Train) Da 52 to come in from Düsseldorf-Derendorf freight station that cold morning. When it did arrive, already delayed at the start of its long journey, the wagons were coupled up to the train. The extended Sonderzug Da 52 now had, in all, nine hundred and ninety-two Jews crammed into its wagons, unable to sit for lack of floorspace. It pulled out of Wuppertal-Steinbeck at around midday and rattled onwards, routed via Hagen, Soest, Paderborn, Lodz, Warsaw and Bialystok to arrive in Minsk on the 14 November. It was a journey of 1700 kilometers completed in ninety-six hours. At its worst, the weather outside was -12 degrees Celsius. There was no heating in the wagons: all that they had was the body heat from each other.

The thirty-six-year-old SS Sturmbannführer and police captain Wilhelm Meurin was in charge of  the sixteen guards on that train. In his report on the journey written for his superiors on the 22 November 1941, he discusses the numerous delays and the logistical challenges of reaching Minsk on that rail route. He writes that 8000 Russian Jews have recently been taken out of the Minsk Ghetto and shot to make way for these new arrivals. Meurin reports that shortly after the 992 Jews were unloaded from the train, some of the younger adults discovered a piano in an abandoned inn somewhere in that part of heavily war-damaged Minsk where Sonderzug Da 52 had arrived. Twenty of them danced around naked and three couples performed sex acts in front of the crowd. Cleareyed Wilhelm Meurin: he writes with such precision and sets out his facts so plainly. He reports that Soviet prisoners of war in Minsk have resorted  to the most desperate acts of cannibalism from their dead comrades to survive, feeding off their livers, lungs and brains.
Only five of the deportees on Sonderzug Da 52 survived the Holocaust and my grandmother, dark-eyed Miriam, was not one of them. I do not know whether she died in the Minsk Ghetto or in the nearby camp of Maly Trostenets on the outskirts of Minsk, which had been turned by the Germans from a prisoner of war camp for captured Soviet soldiers to an extermination camp for Jews in the summer of 1942.
Restitution is the giving-back to someone something they have lost. It is no coincidence that I work as a provenance researcher and restitution specialist in the international art trade. Alongside the millions of lives that were lost during the Third Reich and the Second World War, families also lost their unwritten histories, the stories that should have been passed down from grandmother to grandchild, from father to son. They also lost their homes, both those built out of brick and stone and those of the kind that only exist in our hearts and minds, and which we call our homeland. These countless individuals and families also lost their artefacts, the things that they surrounded themselves with and that were part of their daily lives. These things were, and still are, of emblematic importance to them: items of religious ritual, family photographs and documents, paintings, sculptures, drawings, jewellery, keepsakes and mementoes.
I spend my days researching the stories of objects, from the prosaic to the sublime, and of innumerable works of art of both low and high value that are traded on the international art market, trying to uncover their hidden histories, both for the sake of the things themselves, to fill in the gaps in their history, and for the families who might have lost them during the Third Reich. This métier began with my long investigation into my own family history: I now focus what I learned during that painstaking process of uncovering the layers of my family’s story during the Third Reich onto the lives and histories of other families.
What I have learned above all else is that identity, just like history, is never  black and white. Many European Jews felt themselves to be, and were, completely assimilated. The wealthier ones often collected altarpieces and predella panels, alabaster carvings of saints and medieval woodcarvings of Christ on the Cross or the pietà both because they were beautiful examples of European art and because these Jewish collectors saw themselves as an integral part of European history. The art displayed on their walls and in their homes reflected that history and that culture back at them. It was not they themselves who said that they didn’t belong within those narratives, within those stories. Rather, it was others in the 1930s who told them that those stories were not theirs and could never be theirs.
Alt image
Stacks Image 211
Buy a single print issue of our December 2020/January 2021 edition of The London Magazine or subscribe to The London Magazine and receive a copy bi-monthly.

Fiction of Guilt and Identity

Jewish Book Week 2017 | session 5th Mar. 2017
Alt image
Stacks Image 291
John Steinberg’s Blue Skies Over Berlin is a moving and thought-provoking book about guilt and identity, featuring a young German woman who moves to London from war-ravaged Berlin in 1956. Taking a false name – Charlotte Brown – she lands the job of her dreams at the National Gallery, becoming enmeshed in a world of aristocratic rogues, conmen, thieves and shady art dealers.

Head of Sotheby’s Restitution Department, Richard Aronowitz’s An American Decade is an ambitious novel that takes in the tumultuous 1930s and the subsequent dramatic events of mid-twentieth century history: the Third Reich; the little-known story of the Nazi organisation – the German American Bund; and the Kindertransport.

The authors discuss their work with writer and journalist Jenni Frazer.